Hi! Yep, here I am with an un-edifying follow-up from the incinerator experiment at SECMOL. We did the prototype with Russell Collins of Himalayan Rocket Stoves Australia, Chozang Namgial of Himalayan Rocket Stoves India, and Konchok Norgay director of SECMOL at the time.
I asked Rohit Ranjan, the author, for a follow-up, but we didn't make it a permanent installation. We really should. Here's what I recall with the author's input.
1) We were lucky to have found rolls of dirty ceramic wool discarded in the desert by the Indian army (haha, that's how a lot of garbage goes in the area).
2) The waste inlet was problematic because plastic waste isn't shaped like fuel. It's in awkward shapes, some of them bulky or too compact, etc. I also remember we discussed that some types of plastic melt rather than combusting. It also may need a grill made of high temperature material. So waste inlet design is going to need work.
3) As mentioned in the article, our initial air inlet pipe was insufficient. We were doing this at 10,500 feet above sea level where the air density is very low, so other locations might have less of an issue. Anyway, we were building this with materials on hand at the time.
4) As I recall, the temperature probe was destroyed when we left it in the chimney too long. We'd already gotten several readings at different spots. So if you embark on this type of
project, invest in a good high temperature probe first.
Rohit Ranjan's input:
I think you are mostly correct. But what I remember is the following:
1. When the [senior male] staff member would operate it, it worked well. However, when students or junior staff operated it, it just wouldn't work and dense smoke was produced.
2. Additionally, we never quantified how much fuel was needed as starter, and there was always a complaint that the garbage itself wouldn't burn and people needed to supply extra fuel (wood), which was a hassle.
[Rebecca: wood is in super short supply and valued in Ladakh, where even twigs are used for fuel. This should be a surmountable issue in other climates.]
3. People also say that at one point the students put in a lot of sanitary pads for combusting and that was the end of it, or was it for the Phyang one? I am confused now.
[Rebecca: I heard the one in Phyang ended when villagers stuffed it with diapers/ nappies/ Huggies, so that might be what you remember]