Peter Ellis wrote:
āI cannot get past the sense that you are focusing too much on the trees in the forest

There are multiple layers to the food forest and they are not all about producing fruit. I am not sure that any of the layers are all about producing fruit, in fact. So, if there's an abundance of fruit in the trees, surely you can find balance for that with all the vegetables you grow at the lower levels.
I think your perceived problem is not a problem with the "food forest" concept, but perhaps relates to some executions you have seen, or to your looking at only part of the system rather than the whole thing.
I just don't see an inherent fruit overload as part of the food forest approach. Of course, with any planned garden, you can put too much emphasis on a given product (how much squash do I really need? Now how much more than that am I growing?

), but that is a planning error, not an error inherent to the concept of a planned gardenā.
Yes! I totally agree, those š are the points.
One can set up a food Forest with whatever food plants and animals one wants! Itās the overall plan, with basic structural considerations and plant types, successions, layers, patterns, time considerations, that matter. NOT the specific food type.
One can create a food Forest with no human foods at all, if for example a carnivore diet is followed⦠ie, all the tree and plant forages would be designed, so that season by season, it feeds the full variety of animals one plans to put in oneās forest system.
Re fruit trees: I totally agree that I do not want too many either. We just put in the ones that we care about and eat frequently in the food Forest, placed in a Savannah style system with guilds and inter-associative and supporting plants that work for the land, plants, animals AND what we want to eat.
Personally, We focus on avocados, olives and citrus as every day eating, and plums, apples, native currants, figs, mulberries and apricots as dessert fruit. We donāt eat sweetened food here at all, no āalternativeā or fruit sweeteners either, *only* whole raw or baked fruit as dessert or tea - itās been 15 years. And itās the best decision Iāve ever made.
Mostly though, nuts like acorns, hazels, walnuts, chestnuts are on trial, and almonds are the food trees we chose. And trees and brush that are forage-able by the animals we have, and which also support wildlife in each season.
2 particular fruiting plant that are very useful:
1/Opuntia. The paddles are certainly a definition of an edible ātreeā and the fruit truly are excellent - even un-hybridized varieties. The paddles also serve as *excellent* forage for ruminants and poultry, especially in the summer and fall dry Mediterranean climate.
2/Mulberry: the young leaves are an edible green for humans and the entire tree is invaluable forage (higher protein than legume greens!) for animals especially in the dry season when no green animal forage is available. The pollarded wood is GREAT for my rocket heater and the darn things grow back instantly!! The leaves too!! Such a win-win!! The berries are SO good as well, lacking intense sweetness and dry beautifully for storage.
We donāt eat grains much at all. I wouldnāt miss them in fact. And we donāt feed āfeedsā and āgrainā to our livestock, they get that via the grass seed heads out in silvo pastures. But it isnāt hard to grow them if they are desired. The right variety for the climate is the key š
Wild types of Buckwheat, oats, barley types and amaranth are weeds here, the animals love them, and certainly the hybridized types would grow well, if desired.
There is no reason that interplanting with chosen grains wouldnāt work beautifully in between food Forest plantings..
Just because someone else focuses on fruit doesnāt mean you have to.
As long as there are guild plants and support plants placed according to sun, water cycle, topography and animal involvement as desired, choose the food p okants and animals that work for YOUR family.
Oh and I forgot to say: there is plenty of fresh unrotted fruit and nuts that fall from trees - these are ALL out to great use for our animals. A human is not required to eat all, or even any, of the fruit producedā¦