I think Ryan has the best answer here - it's hard to beat a good 1/2" of soil to give the seeds a good footing.
If you REALLY don't want to pull off the extra mulch, consider broadcasting more seed (like one every square inch!) into the mulch and disturbing it to shake them down close to the soil. Then water really well and do a buckwheat dance over the whole area.
Oh, and think of planting a few peas or favas on the sunny edges -- abundance trumps fallow
