I've seen 5 minute risers. They're pretty good, but not what I'm looking for. Price per performance is surely very good. But they're not "just as good," I mean not on the level I'm thinking about this stuff.
For one thing, they're not smooth or consistent on the inside, which means their performance in terms of friction loss is not equivalent. Perhaps if one were oversized a bit to compensate for inefficiencies, they could approach equivalence.
In terms of thermal conductivity, CFB is a tiny fraction as conductive. ~0.2 vs ~2.5 BTU•in./hr•ft²•°F. And since I'm working with a 2" thick riser, vs 1" thick 5-minute-riser, the difference is double. That's a huge difference, a 25X difference in this case. Now whether or not that makes any sort of difference in a RMH remains to be seen. We're just trying to keep super hot gases away from very hot gases. It may not matter that much.
But again, back to dollars per performance, 5-minute-risers are quite good. But they are not the same thing.
CFB risers are expensive. Just FYI for people wondering, $225 for a 2 foot section of 2" thick 8" ID riser. I would think if someone like me who just can't live with good
enough, a better option might be to use 1 or 2 inch thick ceramic fiber board and build a square riser. For friction loss, you can oversize it a little (which Matt Walker's design does to compensate for being square) to maintain effective CSA, but it will be still be as insulative and you'll pay $153 for a full riser rather than $450 ($93 vs $318 for 1").
You know, you've inspired me. I'm building this system such that the risers can be switched out in minutes. And it will have full temperature instrumentation, and one day I hope gas instrumentation as well. So I might as well do some tests and figure out just exactly what the difference is. I have no doubt that all of them will perform acceptably in a well designed system.
I will say in terms of the original goal of creating inexpensive
wood heaters with commonly available materials, the 5-minute-riser surely succeeds whereas the full CFB core with ceramic fiber riser sleeve riser does not.