I've been obsessing over this very topic lately, happy to find an old discussion on it.
"… if a hog is raised, slaughtered and cured in a manner entirely consistent with what would result in Jamon Iberico de Belotta but for subtracting acorns and adding in pecans, would the end result have a taste consistent with Jamon Inerico de Belotta?"
George-
Generally consistent in taste, perhaps, but I don't think the exact flavor of jamon iberico de belotta could be reproduced outside of Spain. The "problem" wouldn't so much be the feed difference (pecans vs. native spanish acorns) in my opinion, but the whole environment they live in. You could control for as many variables as possible, breed, salting, aging, humidity, air temp., feed, etc., but ultimately I think some foods are really a product of the local
land. This is true of many cheeses, wild plants, etc., and I think it's true of some traditional cured meats as well. There are just too many variables to control for outside of a laboratory, and when people have been creating a product for many hundreds of years in a particular place, there can be no true recreation of that product elsewhere.
Now, I don't really see this as a problem. If you take the general process of making great jamon iberico in the traditional way, and apply it to your pecan-fed pigs on your land, you will probably wind up with a fabulous piece of cured pig ass. The pecans will be fattier than spanish acorns, the pigs will dig up your local
root vegetables instead of mediterranean varieties, breathe the air in your neck of the woods instead of spanish sea breezes, they'll even eat your soil to a certain degree… and of course there's the aging, which as much as we'd like to believe is merely a product of humidity and temperature, is influenced by more subtle environmental factors than we could possibly surmise. In short, your jamon will reflect your terroir, and may well taste better to you than jamon iberico de belotta. Even though I think recreating the precise flavors/textures etc. of a product such as jamon iberico is impossible, doesn't mean I don't think it's worthwhile to pay great attention to the other culture's methods of production. Their tricks of the trade have everything to do with the fantastic final product, and many of them may apply to your situation. But you also might find after years of aging hams that you're better off changing the recipe so to speak, perhaps that will mean more/less salt in the initial drying, different curing temperatures/humidity, different slaughtering time even, who knows what your environment will demand.
A somewhat relevant side story:
Last summer I lived in a small valley in northern Italy, close to the alps. The area is noted for it's salame, which has been produced in a certain way for countless generations. I worked on a small organic farm where they raised a small number of hogs primarily for salame production, and helped take care of the animals for a month before slaughtering day. They were fed a basic grain/corn feed each morning, and turned out into the local woods during the day to forage for nuts,
roots, bugs, etc. We took them to the local slaughterhouse, where a few dozen pigs from another local farm were being slaughtered the same day. The pigs from the other farm were raised on commercial feed, and didn't get to exercise outside in the woods. The difference in the meat, visually, was incredible. Our pigs bore dark red flesh, almost the color of a ripe tomato. The other pigs muscles were a pale pink. The next day, both batches of pork were ground, mixed with the time tested mix of herbs, spices and wine, and cased for hanging. I got to sample both batches of meat (raw pork, a first but how could I say no with these haggard old italian butchers insisting and eating next to me) after being mixed with the spices. etc, and the difference in flavor was tremendous. These were pigs of the same breed, raised in the same valley, processed into salami and aged at the exact same facility. The only difference was that one group got to forage in the woods every day, while the other stayed in their pens.
This doesn't even scratch the surface of differences in cured meats. Salame made the next valley over from pigs foraging in their local woods tasted very, very different from ours. Even under very, very similar conditions, I think your hams will come out more distinct from jamon iberico than one would expect.
Also, what's your plan for curing your jamon? The conservative approach would be to create a sterile environment similar to industrial operations, which I suppose would be necessary if you're producing for sale. Personally, I would prefer to build a root cellar with earthen plastered walls and/or local rock, especially for pork curing. Many italian salumi are still aged in ancient caves, where they take on the local flavors. I've seen this in sardinia, where mountain people still live like their great-great grandparents did. Incredible cured pork products and cheeses there. If you're lucky, the bacteria and fungi (particularly mold) inhabiting your local soil would be beneficial to aging pork. If not, you could identify some other strains of mold used in pork curing which survive well in your temperature/humidity situation and inoculate your aging cellar with said mold.
Best of luck with your project! I've salivated over the thought of American, pecan-fed, cured pork before and am delighted to read about someone in the process of creating it. With your knowledge of the jamon iberico raising/curing process and your land assets, it sounds like you're well on your way to creating a classic american cured meat.