posted 1 year ago
Hard to say.
In the wild, I have seen fruit trees (chokecherry) that are systemically infected with black knot, including the root stock. All new shoots are quickly covered with it.
With my tame fruit trees, I have had good luck with a hard pruning to remove an infected branch. If I was forced to take out the whole tree, I would be skeptical about grafting onto a new shoot. But I think the only way to find out is to try.