posted 12 years ago
Hi K.,
I agree that aesthetics are very important, and as you say, can be with you a very long time indeed. The brick arch is a very nice touch! I like masonry arches, and have done several in dry laid stone for a wonderful affect to the general project. These masonry elements are much more time consuming to do and also, whether materials are free or not, they are costly in the labor, as well as, fiscally. (Very beautiful though, and often worth the effort, if the general theme is heavy and stone based.) Depending on the design, the nice element about all wood and cobb oven units, with only stone at grade level, is ease of construction, and speed of removal/relocation should the need arise. As for aesthetic, because of the 'plastic' nature of cobb, it is much more yielding to artistic endeavors than stone or fired ceramics, from a time and ease of manipulation in the medium. I love stone and as a stone carver lean that way often, but practicality is the forefront of most domestic "cobb oven projects." . I would also add, that of the stone arches I have done, several have been retrofits to what Terry is currently considering, so the masonry can always be an augmentation for a later time should the desire come forth.