Gilbert Fritz wrote:I guess we would have to factor in the impact of cinder mining on the local environment.
While considering externalities, I hope that you consider the environmental impact of mining clay.
I bet that if you visit the stone yard of the company that supplies your local landscapers, that they will have cinders from the volcano. Around here, they often come screened to "pea-gravel" size, which is about 1/4".
When I consider externalities, I often find that doing things myself requires more energy than using materials that are acquired in bulk in far away places... For example. On a per pound basis, it takes more fuel for me to take vegetables 10 miles to market in my pickup than it does to bring them 1200 miles from California on a semi.