posted 7 years ago
I'm actually doing that, having designed the house with a radiant floor and later discovering RMHs
I have two coils of flexible 1/2" copper wrapped around the barrel and a small circulating pump.
I have been told the cheap ebay pump I bought doesn't last very long , but using it as circulating on the cold water side and within a few feet horizontally it seems to do a good job.
I regulate it with a thermostat turning the water circulation on and off to keep the water in the coil from boiling, and keep the system open ie: depressurized so the worst that happens is the thing boils over and out through the shower head in the bath tub.
Explosions (or pipes bursting which is more likely but could still ruin your day) don't happen, although once I had solder melt out of a joint when the pipes ran dry.
If you're using a RMH with a small open firebox, a bucket of sand nearby could become very useful if you needed to extinguish the fire quickly.
An aluminum foil jacket helps the coil heat faster, and I have often thought about taking the sheet metal skin off an old water heater and using that as an even more protective shielding on top of the coil )-- heating hot water can never have too much protection/ backups. If you don't already know a fair amount about plumbing and safe methods of heating water, this is not something you should try at home
My experience would suggest that if you can possibly use the more passive exhaust ducts through the mass it will be a nicer experience with much less maintenance. Some heaters run the exhaust through mass in the walls, and replacing center walls with this style of thermal mass might be an alternative to benches.
Radiant floors are nice, but end up with high maintenance, (thermosiphons won't send water through a radiant system),,and hot water takes lots of btus, so you will likely need something more like a batch burner than an RMH Which is what I'm in process of converting to now after running an RMH for about 3 years. It just takes lots of time and energy to split small sticks and keep a fire going with constant attention---and my house uses very little heat to start with. My batch burner is still under development, burning quite dirty now, but the relief from splitting everything down to 1" or smaller, and having to check it every ten to 15 minutes to add more wood makes it worth learning about.
More and more I'm trying to put things on automatic using less of my attention--developing a hot water system with an RMH can be done, but ultimately there are easier safer ways to heat a house.
Or at least that's how I see it