• Post Reply Bookmark Topic Watch Topic
  • New Topic
permaculture forums growies critters building homesteading energy monies kitchen purity ungarbage community wilderness fiber arts art permaculture artisans regional education skip experiences global resources cider press projects digital market permies.com pie forums private forums all forums
this forum made possible by our volunteer staff, including ...
master stewards:
  • Nancy Reading
  • Carla Burke
  • r ranson
  • John F Dean
  • paul wheaton
  • Pearl Sutton
stewards:
  • Jay Angler
  • Liv Smith
  • Leigh Tate
master gardeners:
  • Christopher Weeks
  • Timothy Norton
gardeners:
  • thomas rubino
  • Jeremy VanGelder
  • Maieshe Ljin
  • Likes 3
  • Mark post as helpful
  • send pies
    Number of slices to send:
    Optional 'thank-you' note:
  • Quote
  • Report post to moderator
Behold the mighty mealworm!  'Tenebrio molitor' aka Mealworms aka Darkling Beetles present a very unique opportunity to the permaculturist entrepreneur and homesteader.

The bugs are favored by birds (including chickens, of course), fish, and reptiles alike as a wonderfully wiggly protein-rich tasty snack.  Furthermore, there is a growing market for insects as a crunchy noodly people-food even, for those whose stomachs can actually stomach the thought of eating bugs.  Insects' high feed conversion ratio make them attractive from an environmental and cost perspective.

The Mealworms have yet another super power however, in their ability to consume Styrofoam.

Yes, you read that correctly, these critters actually eat polystyrene.

So in addition to concepts such as those proposed by "StyrofoamMom", the beetles present a recycling and waste disposal solution or opportunity which helps to actually "obtain a yield."

Our Darkling Diary
Acquiring mealworms:
In late March 2015, my dearest green-thumbed mother, also a backyard bird enthusiastic, purchased 1000 mealworms for ~$10, including a bird feeder, through a promotional deal through Wild Birds Unlimited.  (Btw, did you know you can also purchase bat-house boxes through those stores?)  She took the worms out of that refrigerator and into her home and heart, as well as into the local birds' beaks and bellies.  After a quick trip to Bug Lots...*correction, BIG LOTS discount store...for a small (less than 12" by 6") set of 3 stacking transparent plastic bins, I was able to make a home for these wiggly pioneers.  

Simple frass bug bin how-to:
  • Take a series of plastic stacking bins.
  • Cut out the bottom of most the bins, leaving a ledge around the edge. Reserve one intact bin as the bottom bin to catch frass.
  • Cut a scrap of window screening to size.
  • Apply hot glue to the window screen/box bottom edges.


  • Feeding and care:
  • Ensure the bugs have oxygen via mesh screen, but cannot crawl out of their bug bins.  Vertical smooth plastic is sufficient.  Be aware that any foods or Styrofoam added may shift in the bins, so don't inadvertently let the beetles crawl out by adding too much!
  • The larvae and beetles primary food is originally oatmeal bran.
  • Moisture and nutrients are obtained by the bugs via discarded veggies or fruit scraps (carrot, potato peel, etc)
  • Styrofoam trash can be added in increasing amounts, and will be consumed entirely with no (visible) trace other than normal frass**.
  • Life stages include:

  •    1. Egg.
       2. Tiny tiny larvae -transitioning to--> Larger wormy mealworm larvae.
       3. Cacoon-like white Pupae.
       4. Lively Darkling beetle. --> mating, repeat...

  • Frass is sifted out and used as fertilizer or discarded.  Remember that eggs will likely be present in this frass, so be mindful of where frass is disposed.
  • Remove any material that is not consumed or has become moldy
  • Pupae can be separated and placed in the upper bins to hatch new beetles.
  • Worms can be fed to critters, or freeze dried, or added to new oatmeal bran filled cups to propagate.


  • **Note: Frass is mealworm beetle or larvae poop, a good garden fertilizer.  However, latest research shows that the fire-retardant HBCD is present in mealworm frass if Styrofoam is consumed (hat tip to Polly for the link).  Fortunately, the research is showing that the bugs themselves do not bioaccumulate this specific toxin, and are likely safe for consumption up to the next tropic levels!  That said, the frass must  be treated (or disposed of) accordingly due to the toxin HBCD. For more general discussions on polystyrene-eating, check out the permie posts over here.

    Over the years, my mom's pet bugs and beetles have eaten untold (though very small) amounts of Styrofoam, including trash removed from local wetlands and river waterways.  

    As of March, 2021, these bugs have reproduced through countless life cycles, with minimal support.  They have been forgotten about through several vacations, and yet they persist, +6years later, consuming Styrofoam every year.  That said, they are oft forgotten about, and therefore the quantity of beetles has gone down over the years.

    Possibilities for research and business-oriented Permies:
  • Waste removal: How much polystyrene (volume-wise) will they consume?
  • Production analysis:
  •   -What mass of bugs can be produced per what unit of bin volume and feed mass?
          -What volume of frass is produced?
          -How nutritious is the frass for plants?
          -How can production be automated?  
              -Feeding.  (Auger?)
              -Hydration management.  (Basic temperature and humidity sensor?)
              -Life cycle management. (Batch selection -> Timing? Light adjustment within the bin to encourage beetles or larvae to move from one specific location to another!?  Machine vision, perhaps?  Robotic arm to select out largest, most productive worms?  Temperature adjustment to pause or slow down life cycle for mealworm harvest?)
              -Frass separation and disposal?  (Sifting via eccentric weight, motor, and sieves?) from eggs, larvae, pupae, beetles?
  • Scalability:
  •       -How to neutralize polystyrene waste at a larger scale?
          -How to propagate and make more worms with the least amount of effort?
          -How to safely biodegrade HBCD?
  • Genetic selection: Can the darkling beetles be bred to maximize polystyrene consumption as well as size?
  • What other waste products are readily consumed by the beetles?  (Perhaps spent brewers' grain?  Specific types of leaves?  
  • Guild selection: Where do mealworms best fit with respect to the larger ecological puzzle?
  •       -Inputs/Needs = Containment, Styrofoam, grain, waste veggies, clean air, temperature and light moderation, moisture moderation, waste disposal
          -Characteristics: Small; crawling; climbing; burrowing; pupating; mating; egg laying; cannibalism; avoiding light/preference to dark areas; moisture seeking
          -Outputs/Yields = Protein for chickens/fish/people; Frass (bioremediate via: time?  sunlight?  bacteria?  mycorestoration?; CO2 for plants?
    COMMENTS:
     
    pollinator
    Posts: 553
    Location: Mid-Atlantic, USDA zone 7
    427
    forest garden trees books building
    • Mark post as helpful
    • send pies
      Number of slices to send:
      Optional 'thank-you' note:
    • Quote
    • Report post to moderator
    Now for some pictures of mealworms munching styrofoam, oatmeal, and food scraps.
    1601490244326_image1.JPG
    [Thumbnail for 1601490244326_image1.JPG]
    1601490223790_image2.JPG
    [Thumbnail for 1601490223790_image2.JPG]
    image2.JPG
    [Thumbnail for image2.JPG]
    1601490180904_image1.JPG
    [Thumbnail for 1601490180904_image1.JPG]
    image1.JPG
    [Thumbnail for image1.JPG]
     
    gardener
    Posts: 5169
    Location: Cincinnati, Ohio,Price Hill 45205
    1010
    forest garden trees urban
    • Likes 1
    • Mark post as helpful
    • send pies
      Number of slices to send:
      Optional 'thank-you' note:
    • Quote
    • Report post to moderator
    Love this idea!
    I considered mealworms, but they are evidently  fussier than I want to deal with.
    I "keep" a worm bin,  which is to say,  I  dump stuff in it and occasionally check to see who's winning,  red Wriggler Worms or the Black Solider Flys.
    I have considered adding mealworms and just letting them sort it out.

    I'm concerned about what makes it through their guts unchanged, but I'm sure the information in the links addresses that.

    Funny thing is chickens love to eat styrofoam and meal worms, now we can change one into the other!
     
    pollinator
    Posts: 3756
    Location: 4b
    1358
    dog forest garden trees bee building
    • Likes 1
    • Mark post as helpful
    • send pies
      Number of slices to send:
      Optional 'thank-you' note:
    • Quote
    • Report post to moderator
    I raise thousands of meal worms, and I would really like to see some info on what the meal worms "do" with the styrofoam.  What are they breaking it down into?  Here is a quote from the study:  "In the lab, 100 mealworms ate between 34 and 39 milligrams of Styrofoam – about the weight of a small pill  – per day. The worms converted about half of the Styrofoam into carbon dioxide, as they would with any food source.  Within 24 hours, they excreted the bulk of the remaining plastic as biodegraded fragments that look similar to tiny rabbit droppings. Mealworms fed a steady diet of Styrofoam were as healthy as those eating a normal diet, Wu said, and their waste appeared to be safe to use as soil for crops."

    Half was converted to carbon dioxide.  What was the other half converted into?  They are excreted as "biodegraded fragments".  How do they know?  Have they seem the degradation of the substances?  Their waste "appeared to be safe" isn't convincing enough for me to use it.  Regardless it is interesting and I'll follow it.

     
    George Yacus
    pollinator
    Posts: 553
    Location: Mid-Atlantic, USDA zone 7
    427
    forest garden trees books building
    • Mark post as helpful
    • send pies
      Number of slices to send:
      Optional 'thank-you' note:
    • Quote
    • Report post to moderator
    That's great to hear about your production volume!

    My family's ongoing experiment is obviously *way* smaller... smaller than a shoebox even.  

    But it's been going on 5 years, and that presents opportunities from a genetic perspective, I hope.  With perhaps a conservative 19 week life cycle per generation (based off estimates listed at https://mealwormcare.org/life-cycle/  ) that's potentially well over 20 generations.

    About the poop.

    For those unfamiliar with the substance, the frass is light, airy, brown dusty poop and exoskeleton remains.  It is easily visible in the pictures. It's probably so fluffy, that if you were to sneeze near it, it would likely go *poof* in the air.  Supposedly it is a good fertilizer.

    However, obviously if one doesn't think it's safe or healthy to use, then don't partake in the styrofoam cycling experiment.

    What we can *personally* say from direct observation, is that the shear volume reduction and color transformation is impressive.

    What was once a big brick of white styrofoam trash taken floating from a river (or a takeout container from wherever, etc etc), now just looks like dirt.
     
    Trace Oswald
    pollinator
    Posts: 3756
    Location: 4b
    1358
    dog forest garden trees bee building
    • Mark post as helpful
    • send pies
      Number of slices to send:
      Optional 'thank-you' note:
    • Quote
    • Report post to moderator

    George Yacus wrote:That's great to hear about your production volume!

    My family's ongoing experiment is obviously *way* smaller... smaller than a shoebox even.  

    But it's been going on 5 years, and that presents opportunities from a genetic perspective, I hope.  With perhaps a conservative 19 week life cycle per generation (based off estimates listed at https://mealwormcare.org/life-cycle/  ) that's potentially well over 20 generations.

    About the poop.

    For those unfamiliar with the substance, the frass is light, airy, brown dusty poop and exoskeleton remains.  It is easily visible in the pictures. It's probably so fluffy, that if you were to sneeze near it, it would likely go *poof* in the air.  Supposedly it is a good fertilizer.

    However, obviously if one doesn't think it's safe or healthy to use, then don't partake in the styrofoam cycling experiment.

    What we can *personally* say from direct observation, is that the shear volume reduction and color transformation is impressive.

    What was once a big brick of white styrofoam trash taken floating from a river (or a takeout container from wherever, etc etc), now just looks like dirt.



    George, my problem with it is very simple.  I just want someone to show that the meal worms are doing something short of just taking styrofoam and grinding it into dust.  If I were to take styrofoam, somehow turn it from white to tan, as passing it through a meal worm's system does, grind it into miniscule particles, and mix it into my soil, I don't know how to tell what effect I would have on that soil, or indeed, how long it would take for any effect to show up.  My concern is that the meal worms may be doing just that, and they do indeed make it so it "just looks like dirt".  I hope I'm wrong and this is a way to get rid styrofoam in a healthy, ecological manner. That would be a huge boost to cleaning up one of the messes we have made.
     
    pollinator
    Posts: 2339
    Location: Denmark 57N
    598
    fungi foraging trees cooking food preservation
    • Likes 1
    • Mark post as helpful
    • send pies
      Number of slices to send:
      Optional 'thank-you' note:
    • Quote
    • Report post to moderator

    Trace Oswald wrote:
    George, my problem with it is very simple.  I just want someone to show that the meal worms are doing something short of just taking styrofoam and grinding it into dust.  If I were to take styrofoam, somehow turn it from white to tan, as passing it through a meal worm's system does, grind it into miniscule particles, and mix it into my soil, I don't know how to tell what effect I would have on that soil, or indeed, how long it would take for any effect to show up.  My concern is that the meal worms may be doing just that, and they do indeed make it so it "just looks like dirt".  I hope I'm wrong and this is a way to get rid styrofoam in a healthy, ecological manner. That would be a huge boost to cleaning up one of the messes we have made.



    Since they are producing Co2 from it and in some cases living off it exclusively they have to be using it rather than just physically grinding it up. The question would be how much of it is being used and how much is passing though as micro plastics Styrofoam itself is pretty innocuous as far as ingredients go it's only expanded polystyrene which is (C8H8)n
     
    Posts: 51
    5
    • Likes 4
    • Mark post as helpful
    • send pies
      Number of slices to send:
      Optional 'thank-you' note:
    • Quote
    • Report post to moderator
    Interesting discussion. This is the latest I could find, https://www.intelligentliving.co/styrofoam-eating-mealworms-absorb-toxic-additive/
     
    Trace Oswald
    pollinator
    Posts: 3756
    Location: 4b
    1358
    dog forest garden trees bee building
    • Likes 4
    • Mark post as helpful
    • send pies
      Number of slices to send:
      Optional 'thank-you' note:
    • Quote
    • Report post to moderator

    Polly Oz wrote:Interesting discussion. This is the latest I could find, https://www.intelligentliving.co/styrofoam-eating-mealworms-absorb-toxic-additive/



    That has been my concern all along.

    "Styrofoam typically contains HBCD, which is a highly-toxic flame-retardant chemical. The follow-up study was conducted to examine if this additive accumulated within the bodies of the mealworms when they consumed Styrofoam made with it. Most importantly, they wondered if the HBCD could pass into the farm animals (chicken or fish) if they ate the worms, then into humans if they ate the animals.

    So, what they did next was feed HBCD-treated Styrofoam to a group of mealworms. They kept a control group on the side, being fed a regular diet. Within 24 hours, the group being fed HBCD-treated Styrofoam excreted 90% of the HBCD they ate. After 48 hours, they discharged all of it.

    Styrofoam-Eating Mealworms Don't Absorb Toxic Additive In The Foam
    Credit: Reuters
    The team thinks that the plastic fragments in their gut were responsible for concentrating and then removing the HBCD. When the experiment was over, the team analyzed both groups of worms in terms of their health, and they were equally healthy.

    Then, they fed shrimp the worms to see what effect the HBCD worms had over the ones fed a regular diet. They found no difference between the health of the shrimp fed HBCD worms over the normal worms. Meaning, the worms could safely be used as feedstock.

    However, the droppings cannot be used as fertilizer because they do contain the toxic chemical. Because the droppings contain the harmful additive, they would have to be disposed of responsibly. The research has been published in the journal Environmental Science and Technology.

    The study only tested for HBCD. There may be some other harmful additives in Styrofoam that do not pass through the mealworms so readily. Therefore, the scientists advise to replace toxic Styrofoam with biodegradable or more easily-recyclable alternatives rather than depend on mealworms to break down the waste."



    So according to this, the harmful chemical, in this case HBCD, just passes through the mealworms but is not broken down in anything safe.  And they don't know if other toxic chemicals are being contained in the mealworms bodies.
     
    pollinator
    Posts: 241
    65
    • Mark post as helpful
    • send pies
      Number of slices to send:
      Optional 'thank-you' note:
    • Quote
    • Report post to moderator
    I will buy freeze dried meal-worms for all the eastern bluebirds until the insect population goes crazy in late spring.
    I love the idea on raising them myself.  Probably stay away from the Styrofoam though.
     
    Arthur, where are your pants? Check under this tiny ad.
    Back the BEL - Invest in the Permaculture Bootcamp
    https://permies.com/w/bel-fundraiser
    reply
      Bookmark Topic Watch Topic
    • New Topic