Hi, Melissa,
I just found your post from 4 years ago and see your last update was 3 years ago, so I don't know if you are still in Idaho or have found something suitable or what. Wish I'd found this a year or two ago as I had 30 acres in Appalachian Virginia and was trying to attract people to form a Permaculture community there.
In six years I found only two families, and the first was so God-awful I had to borrow money to buy them out and send them packing. The second family was the opposite, a Godsend, but they had no capital to invest in the property or infrastructure so just rented a space for their RV and exchanged labor for rent. Father was a master carpenter, mother had the greenest thumb I've ever encountered, and the two adult children were also very helpful.
But they never committed to the community idea, and I knew they would leave eventually. I got tired of being broke, far in debt, and unable to develop the farm as I'd planned, so I decided to sell the farm and look for an established community to join. I looked all over that area, TN, KY, and the Ozarks of AR, OK, MO but didn't find a community or a smaller farm that I could manage on my own. I even went back to UT and NV where I had worked for many years. Nothing met my criteria nor was as affordable to buy as Appalachia.
In the meantime, a house I had sold in Maine in 2019 came back into my hands after the buyer defaulted, and I returned to Maine to rehab and resell it. It was a disaster, the buyers had been junkies who lived in absolute squalor. Worse than any of the "hoarder" shows on TV. Took me weeks just to bag up all the trash and haul everything to the dump, more weeks of scrubbing filth, patching kicked in walls, doors, windows, you name it. Kitchen completely demolished. I'll be all winter getting it livable again to sell in the spring. This time without seller financing--I'm not going through this again.
Come spring I will be heading back to Appalachia to find a property that meets more of my 12 criteria than the last place did. It was too steep, too far from a market for my produce, too far from healthcare and suppliers, and the only water source was a spring on a neighbor's property. I had an easement to access it, but it wasn't mine, and it had to be pumped a considerable distance. I won't make that mistake again.
That's a long story to get to the point I'd like to make.
I will be buying more property, a little flatter, a little closer to civilization, and with a good well or other water source(s). If I can line up some people to join me, I will purchase enough acreage for all of us. Working together, we can accomplish a lot more than I can working alone.
My vision is that the land will be in a land trust with the participants/members as beneficiaries. The trust would lease plots to the members who would build their own homes. Banks and other financial institutions, if needed, will lend on construction loans or mortgages for homes with 99-year leases. Each individual would own his/her/their home. A private membership association (PMA), operated like an LLC, would own all the community infrastructure (fencing, barn, workshops, community buildings, equipment, etc., and all members would share in the income/expenses of the PMA.
My plan is that the community would be self-sustaining and produce enough food for the members with a surplus for sale and produce products from other enterprises (pastured meat birds, pork, beef, lamb, etc., maybe cheese, herbs, nursery stock, honey, cash crops like ginseng, ginger, microgreens, mushrooms) to generate enough income to cover all of the costs of operation, tools and equipment, etc., and eventually pay members for their labor and cash invested.
Personally, I don't need much to live on and am willing to commit my savings and retirement income to the project. I made a decent profit on the sale of the farm, and I'll have whatever I get from the resale of this place in Maine as it is debt free, and I have an 800+ credit score, so I won't have any problem financing the land acquisition. I expect the property will have a livable house for temporary accommodations and probably a barn or other out-buildings. I'd like to build a small earth-bermed house into the side of a south-facing hill with a solarium on the south side (think walkout basement with an earthen roof). Anyone looking at it from a distance would see only a greenhouse on a terrace.
If this is of interest to you (or anyone reading this), please PM me with your email address, and I'll get back to you.