posted 10 years ago
If your fireplace is decent sized and solid masonry, you can probably build a RMH in and in front of it that can heat your house, without taking up much more space than the fireplace clearance requires already. Bonus if it is on an inside wall. If the chimney is still safe for the insert to operate, it should be safe for the RMH. What size and material is the flue, and how tall is it?
In some ways this is an ideal conversion situation, as a fireplace will generally be situated to at least look like it warms its room already, and have decent clearances. If the hearth is substantial, it may be able to support an RMH without further foundation work, which in a crawlspace is not difficult anyway. The heating load you describe sounds like a 6" batch box with minimal sized bell would be able to handle it easily, maybe at as little as 20" x 36" built tight to the fireplace, maybe even less if the fireplace is big enough to fit the riser inside.