I'm floored by the "fences are rude" concept as well! It really is startling how different cultural expectations can be. I forgot that tag are required in some places. Honestly, they probably are here too, but no one ever enforces anything. Here there is little standards for the appearance of fences or houses in the county. If its made out of anything purchased its getting fancy; our neighborhoods are full of fences made from scrap parts and scavenged lumber. I used to think it looked horribly tacky, but I've come to see it as just a form of frugality and re-use/recycling. Still, I wanted something more aesthetically appealing, and due to time constraints (college, kids, building a house) I'm settling for a cheap metal livestock fence. I also kind of want deer to be able to roam on the property (although I plan on keeping them out of the immediate food growing area.
I'm sort of between two properties at the moment. We own a house in a small town, and then bought 10.5 acres in the county. The standards are definitely more relaxed out of the
city. So far the new property hasn't given us any issues, other than a small (like 15lbs) black dogs that visits us when we are prepping the site for building. It's so little and meek it just seems doomed.
When my dad was growing up in Kansas, supposedly dogs were expected to feed themselves, although somehow the dogs were supposed to be able to tell the difference between livestock and wild animals. I can't even fathom how that was supposed to work. I have 3 dogs: a Thai Ridgeback (rescued from negligent neighbor) with zero prey drive but a strong guard instinct against other dogs and certain human behaviors, a 30lb mutt (rescued from a house I made a delivery to when I witnessed her being abused) with a small prey drive and is very skittish, and a very old dingo/german shepherd hybrid who does nothing but try to hunt and kill other animals. After working with the last one over the years, I agree that a dog that regularly hunts and eats its meals (she won't touch her dog food in spring because of all the birds and small animals she catches) cannot be stopped without fairly extreme measures. The fencing I had to build to keep her from going on hunting trips was insane. She never got neighbors animals though, just local wildlife (she always brought the bodies back, and the area she got out in was free of farm land) but even with the fencing animals would get in her yard and fall prey to her. When dealing with a dog like that it would be impossible to work with without the owner stepping up and keeping the dog confined. I was so excited the first time a bird landed next to my Thai Ridgeback and he just looked at it with bored indifference!
Regardless of the temperament of the dog, I 100% agree that they should be kept from roaming. I grew up in New Mexico where there were a lot of starving coyotes and any pet under 40lbs left outside was dead by nightfall. In TN people tend to be more lax because it takes longer for pets to meet bad ends, but it still happens with cars, other animals, and such.
Ack, my kids are climbing all over me while I try to type this. I apologize for incoherency and poor editing. I've been trying to type this off and on for what feels like days now, and I think I'm going to quit before it gets deleted by stray fingers ;p