You, and your son, have fell victim to one of the classic permaculture blunders! The most famous of which is "Don't make a swale off contour", but only less well known is this: Compost can be made successfully in a variety of ways!
Anyone like the Princess Bride? No? Okay I will get back on topic.
Personally, I would encourage you son to continue to do what he does in the view of it being an experiment. Is it still breaking down? Is it still full of worms as he works it? Consider large scale composting processes and their success when they turn windrows.
That is a lot of material and power being moved at a rip! I would figure that your son MIGHT not be every worms friend when he turns the pile but I would imagine the population would recover just fine. As some oversight, take a peek yourself and perhaps coax out questions to get his thought process going on if something is seeming to have a positive, neutral or negative effect?