posted 11 years ago
As to the original question, any thermometer that can be stuck into the soil about two inches and registers temperatures in the range of 30 to 80 degrees will work. A mercury thermometer will be more accurate, but instant read digital thermometers are more convenient. The mercury will take several minutes to register accurately, depending on how far the mercury has to travel, so to speak. A non-digital, non-mercury, that is a bi-metal, thermometer will be calibrated to a certain temperature (eg. 350 for an oven thermometer) and its accuracy will decline as temperatures vary from that sweet spot. Even so you can follow warming trends as get in the ballpark.
John's answer was very helpful. I figure for most people the information they can get online will meet their needs. But you can still learn a lot about your local growing conditions with a soil thermometer. My "local stations" are 50 and 80 miles away and 1000 and 2000 feet lower in elevation and I expect they are going to give more approximations only. They aren't reporting soil temps now and I don't know when they'll start up in spring. I know from experience I can put plastic over a bed for two weeks and plant several weeks earlier than I would otherwise. My own thermometer allows me to monitor this process.
I have monitored soil temperatures and air temperatures at plant level pretty extensively in figuring out how best to use low tunnels and hoophouses to extend my high desert growing season. I've used instant read digital thermometers to determine how much mulch cools the soil and how much freeze protection you get from various weights, layers and combinations of row cover directly over plants, on wire hoops just above plants, and on pvc hoops further above the plants. I learned that plastic low tunnels give lots of heat on a sunny day, but basically no heat retention at night. Row cover protects at night, but does a better job if covered with plastic. A layer of the lightest cover directly over the plants is beneficial if there is another layer held above it by hoops. Part of my garden is protected by a south facing cinder block retaining wall. For every 3 or 4 feet away from this wall, the soil temperature in early spring decreases a degree or two until at 15 feet or so there is no warming effect.
Every year, every season is slightly different. I haven't made any correlations with "pest" pressure. Gophers are active year round and seem to appreciate that I warm the soil with low tunnels for them.
Old-timers say plant corn when the oak leaves are in mouse ear stage. Having the experience to make such observations is even better than looking at soil temperatures.
I'm in the foothills of the San Pedro Mountains in northern New Mexico--at 7600' with about 15" of precipitation, zone 4b historically--growing vegetables for the local farmer's market, working at season-extension, looking to use more permaculture techniques and join with other people around here to start and grow for farmers markets.