posted 11 years ago
Whenever it's suggested that plants are to be grown in a specific medium like manure or compost I'm reminded of all the macro and micro nutrients that plants need to be really healthy and produce at their very best. It is very unlikely that any single manure or compost contains all of these elements which is why adding organic diversity to soil produces the very best results. I would mix that manure with some compost and good topsoil and (dare I say it), maybe even a little peat moss to produce the best planting mix.
(ponder this: manure from a grass fed cow may be sought after for the organic garden. But the manure is the waste product after the cow has extracted the nutrition it needs. Adding the grass directly (or indirectly as compost) to the soil seems to make more sense [unless you have cows and lots of manure!]...?)
To understand permaculture is simply to look at how nature has been growing things for thousands of years. The 'secret' is simply to keep the soil covered with plants or mulch.