posted 10 hours ago
it might be both! cedar apple rust generally doesn’t leave whole dead ‘scorched’-looking branches or twigs like fire blight does.
the when to cut your losses and get a different tree (maybe a different species?) question has a couple factors. the biggest one is how infected is it? the general control measure is to cut off fireblight-infected branches ~16 inches from infected parts (generally visible as dark/grey/black wood). if doing so wouldn’t leave you with much tree, and you already know it’s susceptible to fireblight, it’s probably reasonable to try something else there. if it’s only little bits that can be controlled with a little bit of maintenance, maybe not?
by all means, post pics!