Hi Anne,
To add to the reasons already given.
For me, the advantage of the fireplace was the general good feeling I got from a roaring fire as well as the fact that I had conquered the method of having long controlled burns (light the fire at one end of the logs and have the fire slowly advance lengthwise like a cigarette).
The negative has been that each year those logs get heavier. While I can still handle them now, I want things in place for the day that I can’t.
The fireplace is massive. Lots of 1970s brick. So, the stove sits away from the fireplace and heats up the brick nicely which radiates heat for hours after the fire in the stove had died down.