posted 10 years ago
What size is the existing chimney flue? And how tall? What condition is it in? If it is lots larger than your RMH system size, or if it is in poor condition, you may want to put in a liner (I have heard of stainless ducting used for this). Otherwise, as long as the chimney is at least partially built into the house, you would be better off using it. A cold plug on starting is an issue in some circumstances. How cold are your winters?
Going straight out the wall will not help you; you would then have to run a new metal chimney all the way up above the roof, and it would get even colder than the masonry chimney. A terminal at room level will only work if you have 100% reliable prevailing winds and your exit is on the downwind side. There are only a few places in the world where that is true.
How thick is the masonry on the exterior side of the fireplace? Is there an air gap or any insulation? What does the outside look like? (Is it beautiful or visually prominent?) If it is not visually important outside, you could cover it with some insulation and a new shell. This would let you use the fireplace mass as part of your system, which could save you some space in the room.