Thanks for the feedback everyone! I took two forks as suggested (dipped them into a pot of boiling
water for a few minutes first) and dug around. No mycelium to be found. I has pasteurized the straw by boiling for an hour but temps were unknown though, no thermometer handy. As for tools from latex gloves, to scissors, to the bin, all were wiped down with rubbing alcohol before it touched anything.
I think I’ll wait about another two weeks and dig again just to be sure as to not waste a good slice of bread. Deep down I’m thinking it’s mold too to be honest. I guess I’ll stick to the stropharia in the yard this spring. Just thought and heard that oysters were supposed to be very easy as well.
Thanks all