Howdy All,
What an interesting topic for exploration. Mathew your three theories are intriguing; I'd like to add fourth for consideration. A primer first, I usually think of dogs and animals in general as still being themselves, natural and instinctive. To put it another way, they communicate with with their world and receive their world directly. There is no story or lens in the way and which interprets the world. I'm not saying I know what's going on with animals; I am saying, I think it's something like this and that lets me move to the real point of the matter. Dare I say it, most?, all? indigenous peoples, natural peoples, and probably your Great Grandmother or Grandfather in your lineage, have explanations of how they came to use medicinal plants. Prior to lore, they communicated with plants, had relationships with plants and the plants communicated with them. I realize that this last statement can evoke derision or support or other things depending on an individual's worldview. You know the a priori, unconscious assumptions that one agrees to before anything else. If one's "story of the world" one's metaphysics, do not include such a thing as plant communication, that person doesn't experience it, ever, because it can't happen to them. They have already decided that. And of
course you know, modern physics bears this out, light being both particle or wave depending on the experiment, read point of view. Or, perhaps the most telling, an experiment which is observed by an observer alters the experiment's outcomes. Really. Our position in the world, what we believe, changes our world, figuratively and literally.
Well, suffice it to say Descartes' legacy, I think, has a hand in all of this; reductionism gone awry and the world and living things are soulless and don't feel. It's been awhile since I read Descartes, however, I think I have that last bit correct too. Back to your dog, perhaps we don't even have to come up with theories. Your dog "knew" and followed their knowing. We've all experienced that, knowing something without knowing how we know it, yet still knowing we do in fact know it, without equivocation. By the way, there are
books about these kinds of things and they are a pretty good read; there are also classes in which this kind of relationship to life is taught. Imagine that!
Let's all look to creating a better world because it's what we believe and what we do and dogs have the wisdom, however they came by it, to heal themselves with a bit of willow.
Thomas
Mitama farm