posted 16 years ago
I did soaker hoses many, many years ago. And then I explored different forms of drip (which I didn't like as much as the soaker hoses). And then I remember doing a lot of research into processes that wick instead. I think the last thing I looked into back then (1997 or so) was the idea of saving plastic tubs and burying them in raised beds. As moisture came along, the tubs would fill and some small bit of water would be left in the tub. Roots could get as little or as much as they wanted. I was a little nervous about anaerobic things happening there. In the end I never tried it.
Okay, back to soaker hoses. What about replacing soaker hoses with hugelkultur?
One of the down sides of a soaker hose is that your extra water is rinsing away soil nutrients. And slowly converting your soil into dirt. And then there is the expense and care of the soaker hoses and all of the other bits and bobs you need to get them to work well.
Granted, a hugelkultur bed doesn't really sing until the second or third year - so for the first year it seems that soaker hose might be good. But I think I would still like heavy mulching and some hand watering better.
But, as always, that's just me. There's more than one way to skin a cat.