Hi Dale.
N°2 is impractical, as it would smoke, and be the same as having an open forge imho.
Well, first of all, what do you want to do exactly with your forge? What kind of size and shape? Having a small fire underneath, that's not too daft. Could start the forge on wood. I mean, put wood at first on the bottom, which in turn would light up the charcoal or coal on top. But tending both fires could be a bit of a chore. This could be a solution. I think, forget about removable basket. Forge are fuel guzzlers by nature.
The other solution is a rocket forge with some mass in the riser. So it wouldn't loose succion when you open the door.
Satamax Antone wrote:http://donkey32.proboards.com/index.cgi?action=display&board=experiment&thread=540&page=1
http://sphotos-f.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash3/527008_2350385856496_1720650119_n.jpg
http://sphotos-d.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc6/208893_2350386256506_1683049651_n.jpg
But it's a diferent type, it's not an open forge, but rather an oven type. Here, i've drawn it long, but could somehow be made square. That's why i was asking about what's the main purpose of the forge you want. If for long stuff, knives, swords, spears etc, what i've drawn could be adequate. If for doing stuff like spirals and the like for forged steel gates, doors etc, the long shape is no good. Then a square one, with two sides closed, and two sides with sliding up and down doors. Tho, that would afect the burn much, and the draft too, stealing air from the bottom flow through the grate. But i can't see any other way to do it, than oven style. Mind you, the Canyoon/Donket/peterberg batch rocket could also reach the proper temps.
Well, that's just my opinion.