Thanks guys, this info is super helpful. Its been a while since I've had my head in the RMH stuff. Our building plans have taken many turns and delays, so my head has been other places for a while. We are getting back to the
project on our
land, and I'm having to refresh. I had remembered that the stove body temperatures were relatively low (at least compared to a box stove), along with bench and exhaust temps being even lower. So 36" just seemed like over kill to me. 4" seems a lot more reasonable. I figure if its not unsafe for a person to sit on the bench, it should be alright for it to be pretty close to combustables! Not sure if an insurance adjuster would agree with me on that, but I'm not stressing about that for this build.
I also contacted Matt Walker and his recommendation was in line with yours, Thomas. 4" from combustables, reduced to 2" if you use a heat screen like you described. Since the heat screen is itself 1" or more thick (made from 1xs), the heat screen is really only gaining you an inch.. so I think I'll just plan for 4" allowance all around. That is certainly obtainable!
Thanks again for your guy's input! Its really nice to be able to post something and get some reliable feedback quickly! Really appreciate it.