When something dies the residue is carbon and other minerals. To convince me that growing something that then dies is carbon neutral, you would have to show me that the carbon is then oxidized to form carbon monoxide and or carbon dioxide. The oxidation takes place by burning with oxygen or by decomposition by biological activity.
On the subject of global warming.... 98% of the scientists have the opinion that global warming is real and a threat to the survival of mankind. It is my opinion that the remaining 2 % are paid by the organizations that want to continue to burn fossil fuels or are ill informed and hope to make a name for themselves by taking a position that is contrary to the majority.
I am 79 years old and I remember the clear skies of 1940, when you could see for hundreds of miles. I am a private pilot and from 10,000 feet, looking down, the earth is relatively clear but when you look horizontally you realize that you are looking through
pea soup. I flew from Phoenix to Mazatlan, Mexico. It is 770 miles. For the first 400 miles the air was cloudy with pollution. When I was over Mazatlan, the air was crystal clear. Cabo San Lucas, Mexico was 204 miles away and there was not a trace of pollution in the atmosphere. The only comparable view I have had, has been to look at photos taken from orbiting space ships.
Incidentally, I am a scientist. I have a bachelors and a masters degree in engineering and all of the
course work for a PhD from Stanford University. I was awarded 5 US Patents for my inventions when I was a staff scientist at Motorola Semiconductor Products in Phoenix, Arizona. In 1970 I chose to leave Motorola and to buy my farm in Camp Verde, Arizona.