We haven't had any smells with this one. We last opened it up about 3 months ago. It's been running for almost 5 months.
We try and strain out big stuff, but inevitably, there is stuff that gets by, and that's really why we have the biofilter. Our wicking bed system eventually backed up and we had to clean it out, which was nasty as hell! So, I know what years of little bits of stuff getting by can eventually do.
But, this seems to work great. The second stage had no noticeable grease, and I opened up the wicking bed inspection, and everything looked great and water flowed through the system beautifully.
There weren't any other critters in there, just earthworms. And while we were inspecting it and taking photos, we had hens that really wanted to get in there and get to the worms. But, we didn't let that happen, and the spent filter material went to our
flow-through worm bin to save any eggs or worms that might still be in there.
We will certainly post updates about it as it goes. If I had to change anything, it would be to make things a bit easier to get in and out, but generally, it works great.