posted 9 years ago
I think the proper way to look at the question of "humane" is ensuring that a paddock is large enough to provide the cows enough forage for the time they're in it. Most likely, the point at which a given paddock is too small to be considered humane in regards to space is going to require such frequent moves (as in, many multiple times per day) as to be untenable anyway. To put it in concrete terms, if you move the cows no more than four times per day (and on a good, highly diverse farm, you certainly have better things to do than move them even that often), the paddock size for each move ought to give them plenty of space to move about.
Paddock shape comes into play, too. A long, rectangular paddock gives them a bit more room to stretch their legs than a square one of the same square footage.
Other factors might include whether or not you want to give the girls space to run (and adult cows do like to run on occasion, and not necessarily as a fear response), whether they have access to sufficient shade, etc.