Our food choices of out of season food is not dictated as much by availability, but by quality and price. Now by "our" I mean as a collective family of husband and wife, and four kids under age 12.
Price: I can buy asparagus year around, but in another month a pound of it will go for 99 cents instead of the $2.99 it is now. We still buy it on occasion, but we buy a whole lot more when it is in season and a lot cheaper. Now that is just an example, we do that with many in or out of season foods.
Quality:
Again I can buy strawberries year around, but out of season they have a very bland flavor. So we do not buy them much until they are in season and the flavor improves. Again, this is just an example of but one, of many things that we buy.
As for the Buy Local movement; I am unsure of how I feel about that.
In some ways it is good, and certainly as a farmer I have sold locally and reaped the benefits of that, but I do worry about the long term effects to my fellow farmers. This is Maine after all, and a very rural place. This county also happens to have the lowest income/highest poverty level of any county in all of New England (ME, NH, MA, VT, CT, RI). That means a lot of the food produced here, especially the high end organic food, is shipped to places like Boston, Providence, Hartford, etc where they have the money to afford such food. This is what is required here because we have the youngest age of farmers in the nation, and the most start-up farms, and with the Maine Organic Farmer and Gardeners Association nearby, an Environmental College known nationally, I say this is the capital of Permiculture for a very good reason. People buy a few acres here, get started in farming (as the numbers prove) then try to compete with a ton of other people doing the same thing. With the Farmers Markets flooded and no longer accepting new farmers, these small and micro-farms take their food and
sell it where they can generate a higher price and meet their fiscal needs. Now there is nothing wrong with that, in fact Maine has been feeding the rest of New England for centuries.
But if the Buy Local movement permeates the cities like Boston, Hartford and Providence; and with Urban Farming gaining in productivity, it could potentially ruin a lot of my friends and neighbors who rely on that market. Again no one is doing anything wrong here; I applaud Bostonites for buying local, and I applaud my neighbors for raising organic produce and selling it where they can, but Buy Local, coupled with Urban Farming, could destroy a lot of Permiculture and Organic farms here that rely on that market.
Now I say all this as an outsider, and in deep respect of those that come here and try to make a go of farming. They really don't have a back up plan, they must make the farm pay for itself, and to that they have my deepest respect! I am a next-generational farmer on the other hand; and while I did buy my farm and did not inherit it, my debt to acres ratio is very low. That is why I can raise sheep and am not have to rely on the high income potential of veggies that can be grown on just a few acres. So being able to stand back, gives me a different perspective.
The only way I see the end being good to my friends and neighbors, is by getting the poverty rate down in this county. Then, and only then could locals actually Buy Local.