The plastic "protectors" did quite a lot of damage there, bark in the first picture was either rubbed off or rodents got under the protector and had a feast, the second photo is rub damage from the protector.
While those things are good there is a point where you have to remove them or damage like you are seeing happens.
Usually protectors are only used while the
root system gets established.
If the tree in the top photo has any growth above the graft, it should make a comeback, the bottom tree will recover since the bark has healed over the wounds.