posted 4 hours ago
I don't think there's an easy answer. There are many variables and many differing opinions.
The new shingles on my cabin and garage were very different from the gooey old asphalt slabs they replaced. My choice was to give the new shingles a year to bake and freeze and wash off. I still collected the water and put it on non-garden shrubs. There was never a hint of a hydrocarbon sheen in the barrels. After that, I chose to use the water in the garden.