Forums Login/signup

Shale for rubble trench?

+Pie Number of slices to send: Send …
I am planning a cob house and have a lot of shale on my property. Does anyone know if shale is suitable fill for a rubble trench?
+Pie Number of slices to send: Send …
How deep is your trench going to be to get below the frost line?  I am going to guess you are looking at 36 to 48 inches?  What is your base soil type?

My concern with shale would be shifting.  It could be contained with a wire gabbion.  A more practical way would be to add gravel as you filled.  Shale would take up a lot of volume and reduce the amount of material that would need to be brought in; but a deep layer of shale will shift and settle.  With frost heaves and expansive soil, I think you will not be happy with shale alone.  It would not take a lot of gravel but needs something to stabilize the lateral forces.  

I don't have shale in my area, but have hiked in areas that was heavy shale.  Uncontained and/or unstablized, I think you would have problems.  I envy you though.  I think it would be a good resource for natural building.  
+Pie Number of slices to send: Send …
I think shale would be okay.

It would be contained within a dug trench, and really it is just a static load that you are putting on top of it. Once the shale shifted and settled in, it would be able to support the static weight of a home I would think. Really the "rubble" is to ensure water is drained away, and that frost does not play havoc under the structure.

I would think the hardest part would digging a trench down to depth if you have so much of it nearby. That kind of says bedrock is pretty close to the surface of the ground, but sometimes you can shatter the shale enough a you are digging to make the trench.

I only semi-have shale here. We have what is called shalely-ledge.
+Pie Number of slices to send: Send …
Thanks for those opinions. Our frost line is 12”. I had planned to dig around 24” deep x 24” wide, line with feed bags and hoping to avoid putting a pipe in. It is a very well draining area. I could easily put part shale/ part rocks. That may just ease my mind enough.
Whose rules are you playing by? This tiny ad doesn't respect those rules:
grow your own garden and build your own home in the gardening gardeners program
https://wheaton-labs.com/bootcamp
bootcamp Paul Wheaton Tour of Wheaton Labs movie Sepp Holzer Desert or Paradise Documentary


reply
reply
This thread has been viewed 1053 times.
Similar Threads
Plan to build timber frame w/cordwood infill in Upstate New York - suggestions, advice, experience?
Foundation inner walls
Please Help me Design a Tiny Cob Home :)
Pole barn with cordwood walls in central arkansas frosts depth of 12".
Cob Rubble Trench Foundation & Water Drainage
More...

All times above are in ranch (not your local) time.
The current ranch time is
Nov 20, 2026 15:34:40.