posted 3 years ago
Insulating bees is a dark art, and bee health issues are frequently misidentified - especially when people are looking at a box of dead bees months after the event when spring finally comes around.
Bees are not humans. Don't heat a large drafty house. The image you want to have in mind is more like that of penguins on the antarctic ice. They huddle together for warmth. The middle ones are snug while the outer ones get cold. When they are cold they consume honey stores and vibrate their flight muscles to generate warmth. When very cold they go into a condition called "torpor" where they appear lifeless but revive when the weather warms.Overly warming the colony in the middle of winter can be actively harmful - they wake from torpor, consume more stores and will attempt cleansing flights. If the external air temperature is too cold the bees may get chilled and be unable to return. Moisture can kill - but frequently this is misdiagnosed, and misdiagnosis leads to poor decision making. Water condensing on the internal surface of the roof drips down onto the colony, chilling and killing bees. Insulating the roof is THE most important step to protecting colonies from winter cold kill due to moisture. Condensation on external walls is less of a problem - the bees will not come into physical contact with it, and in fact are known to drink droplets of condensation through the winter to aid their digestion of honey. Large entrances allow lots of air exchange, which can reduce condensation issues, but the trade off is it makes it harder for the bees to limit and control air flow through the hive.
Personally I have chosen to side step these issues by only using polystyrene hives. It is a compromise - using synthetic materials - but one I think gives conditions much more favourable to the bees. I find that the highly insulating hives very very rarely have moisture issues (woodpecker damage once allowed water in), and the bees use less stores and build up faster in the spring.
After 6 years of keeping bees without any treatments, varroa still remains my most common source of colony loss.
Moderator, Treatment Free Beekeepers group on Facebook.
https://www.facebook.com/groups/treatmentfreebeekeepers/