Starsky, "and now are experiencing an interesting scent coming from that room. Its not necessarily a 'bad' smell, just significantly different from the rest of our house
I don't have experience with earth finishes though this makes me wounder if you are just smelling the "earth".
I know when I clean the walls in a room the room smells "fresh". Or the same effect when I paint a room.
You mentioned sealing it. What are your plans to you plan to leave it as is or apply a coat of paint?