posted 11 years ago
Thanks for the idea. It sounds good, but there may be other things to consider. For example, keep in mind that water is a two way street and it is possible that if it is wet below and drive above, the water will wick up the stick into the air from the ground, drying it out more than if there were no stick. I have not tried your method so I don't know if that would happen, but something to look out for. Also, if you are driving logs into the ground, you may damage roots; how many of these do you put in near each tree? Also, the sheer mass of material may suffer from this method. With a hugel bed, you can easily throw a full few trees in a good sized bed. If you're just using prunings (which you'll need pretty straight branches in order to drive them any distance at all) you may not get that huge network, which brings me to my last point. The huge web of mycelium and bacteria is beneficial as well as the decaying wood. Think of a hugel bed as being a huge metropolis of life and (I'm not sure because I've never had experience with your method,) and you method seeming like a bunch of small towns. I don't know if the analogy works, but take from it what you will.
I'd be interested to see how this works long term. It would certainly be easier than other alternatives. Give it a few years and if it works, let us know and I'll do it too!