Hi Mariah,
Sorry I forgot to answer your question about "cold roofs and rainscreens."
So, let me get that one out of the way.
These two elements are extremely important and in some areas of Canada the are required in all architecture according to localized building code...a good rule of the all too many "stupid rules" that are in code.
When we build today there is this huge push for "air tight" systems closing in a living space. So efficient are these that homes can work without a very well balanced air intake system. Well this would actually be a "good thing"...IF...it would work. However, like so many "bright ideas" that humans come up with and only do limited testing in labs or worse by actually building with them...we have to wait till its too late to figure out..."oops, that does work as well as we thought."
Part of this system is wrapping everything in this allegedly "breathable plastics," (which they are not!) Then we further wrap the structures in more
water proofing on the roof and usually asphalt shingles, and often metal or plastic siding. When on other occasions we go for the "fake natural look" by using wood siding and wood shingles we can't understand why these won't hold paint and rot so quick. Well it is because there is not "real" air circulation and actual permeability (breathability) to the system.
I can give a good (one of many) examples of modern traditional looking Capes built in places like Maine (similar to your area in climate but with much colder winters.) "Real" vintage Capes are timber frames, and the exterior walls are clad in cedar shingles that are not connected directly to the sheathing boards (in the better built versions.) These shingles are attached to a second layer of runner and purlins that create an "air gap" behind the shingles that allow air to circulate up and often into the "cold roof" further creating a "chimney effect" that carries moisture away and dries the siding from both sides. The modern Caps don't have this and the sill latex paints further trap moisture and the shingles decay and the paint peals...
So the simple answer is...a rainscreen and cold roof system is a way to vent behind siding and the roof material to dry it out effectively, and to carry to a certain degree moisture from inside the interstitial zones of walls...if...the structure is designed to be "draft proof" yet still have "breathable wall systems and finishes.
I love the wall truss system, allows you to build super thick, well insulated walls. So, next (obvious) question: what infill would you use? I believe you suggested mineral wool batt, what about densely packed cellulose? Other options?
I use whatever infill is the most cost effective, with the highest R (or U) value per the given design matrix...with the assumption it falls within the parameters of "traditional and/or natural" as well as, has a long proven empirical track record of success. So many "modern methods" are marketed and sold as "the way to do something," and most of them are "I think" concepts with no "long proven empirical track record"...These modern systems grew mainly out of the
greed bred in the large companies that came from the Industrial Revolution (IR) not actual "good practices" in designs for building.
My first choice, if time and resources allow, is a 100% onsite made natural system from only local resources, like cobb, cordwood, log, sawdust,
straw bale, recycle felt carpet padding, bousillage cobbing, light straw clay, wood chip slip, etc etc. The next is mineral wools which have been around for over 100 years and is a waste stream removed by product...Two big pluses that only get better considering mineral wool has none of the short falls found with cellulose. I can not tell you how often I take sopping wet cellulose out of walls that are "sealed" to prevent moisture from getting in them by house wraps and inside air barriers as well as other silly things like "breathable latex (i.e. plastic) paint, modern sheetrock plasters, and related nonsense...None of which work for very long...so...ergo the wet gobs of gooey cellulose in my hands...Then the fingers start pointing at all the reasons this happened, yet never seem to land of the fact that this "I think" concept really does not work...never has...not even a little bit. It is not a matter of "if they will fail" but "when they will fail" and how long it will take for the mold and other stuff to rot the wall and/or make folks sick?
Do the "ribs" not create thermal bridges across the wall thickness? (I suppose this would apply equally to regular stick-framed walls)
None of any significance within the overall context of the wall. There are more and more "net zero" all natural builds taking place every year, and more that are sure to come...
What other layers are there in this wall structure? Gypsum (drywall, yes?) on the inside? Vapour barriers? And what sort of exterior cladding can be used?
On the "down and dirty" and less expensive, "let's get this done jobs," there is no plastering usually taking place to get the project to turnkey status.
Absolutely no vapour barriers of any kind...this is what causes the rot in the long run and I battle this demon with the alleged "experts" all the time. We won't to achieve a "draft proof" yet breathable wall/roof system...not a submarine or spaceship that can't function without a mechanical lung. I am not against a good "air to air heat exchanger" if a client really wants one, they aren't a negative per se, but I don't want the building (and its occupants) to have to really 100% on one for the oxygen they breath or a functional building dynamic.
The exterior is clad in wood (usually ship lap, board and batten, or live edge (a.k.a "Adirondack") siding) and the inside with more boards that can be oiled,
milk painted or limewashed should a more colorful and/or bright finish be desired. The interior can also be covered in textile panels as another fast and flexible wall treatment system. Wood is also a good base for plaster work of all types in the future should one wish to do so. I love (there are only a few of us here in North America that can do it) "paper plasters" what is called "liquid silk" or "liquid paper" plasters.
So you have a thick wall filled with wonderful insulation - is the idea to make this wall breathable? If not, is the home sealed tight and an air exchanger used?
You know my thoughts on this by now...
Wrap-around porch, why is this needed? I confess, I've always disliked them (I totally get why you would want them in places that get super hot). Our winters are dark, grey and dreary and I want as much light as possible streaming in through the windows. And I want to see the sky out my windows! And how does that work with passive solar anyways?
The larger an over hang the longer and better siding lasts, is one main reason for them. Aesthetics are another, as most folks love the character and look of wrap arounds. If they are built correctly, oriented right and the structure is naturally elevated to be up off grade (too many house sit right at grade) then the do not lend themselves to a "dark house" at all, but rather a cool house in summers when the sun is high, and a warm house in winter when the sun is low.
I admit, I have never been a big fan of "passive solar designs." Don't get me wrong, I know of some great one that work and many that look wonderful, yet these are the exception...not the rule for the majority of them. They either only work half as good, have issues with the oversized window slowly failing, and other mitigating challenges.
Now...if someone wants to attach a
greenhouse with a breeze way or atrium connector that can be completely closed of in the warmer months, I am all for that!
As for "seeing the sky" for my "sun-sky" lover clients we put large sky lite window or related clear cladding on the porch roof where the wall windows are or we have full "clearstory" fenestration systems designed for the structure...not a "down and dirty" aspect of a low cost build. Besides, porches do not block as much winter sun as most folks think...
Also, the bottom line is...its your house...if you don't want porches...don't have them. There absence isn't a show stopper, but you may have a "hotter house" in the summer or lots of curtains to shade the house, or heavy deciduous tree cover to block the sun...It is all hard to consider with out photos of a building site...which is my next request, if you can get them...
Regards,
j