... is the condition of these geese from them beating each other up, from predators harassing them at night, or something else I'm not thinking of?
What are anyone's suggestions for dealing with this situation as I would like to continue to be friends with them
The reason they give for not giving them back is that there is one goose that will not come anywhere near them and just has learned to keep her mouth shut and they think that somehow they will train all the other geese to be like that one.
Friends help you move. Good friends help you move bodies. This tiny ad will help:
2020 Permaculture Design Course for Scientists and Engineers, June 14-27https://permies.com/wiki/permaculture-design-course-2020