Again, I would repeat my thoughts that herbal medicines, and how they behave in a person's system, are going to vary greatly from individual to individual; this is much the same as diet.
The Herbal ABC's book that I have from Sharol Marie Tilgner (which i got for free from a recent promotion at Permies) indicates that skullcap is ok fresh or dried, and is recommended as an infusion. I actually take the skullcap tincture at this time, from the herbalist I saw, and haven't got any dried yet. Tilgner seems in agreement with S Buhner on St John's Wort being ineffective dry. Perhaps it is just ineffective to make a tincture from the dried plant? Tilgner seems to be adamant about it's uselessness dried, period.
I can't say either way if it is outright effective for me. I know that my symptoms have greatly reduced, but also they were never to the point that I was in absolutely terrible shape/clinically depressed/anxious, and I have removed a lot of the stressors from my life in the meantime. I just need some support to readjust my system.
My friend, however, has had great success with first charging her system with dried st johns wort infused as a tea, and later, a simple cup of tea (dried herb from the same supplier as me) at night to keep her on balance. She never took a tincture. This has been very effective for her, as she said she would not be able to function at all without having it.
I take it last thing at night after supper / before bed, as well as first thing when I get up before I have anything else, and have some (at least one cup) in the afternoon. I will continue with this type of therapy as well as the tincture until I feel that I have reached a balance, and then I will slowly reduce them.
I have young plants started from seed for two kinds of skullcap and a lesser quality St. John's Wort grows here...I just need to 'cultivate' some.
considering the above, I would like to make my own tincture from fresh SJW plants to see if I get much difference. The only place that I know it is growing here, however, is by the train tracks (which is too toxic for me want to harvest). I am considering taking some from the train tracks and transplanting it on my property and letting it spread for future harvests.