Goal #2 -- A week's worth of supplies
Small Single Burner Propane or Butane Camp Stove -- These little stoves fit right on your kitchen counter and set up in 3 min or less using the 1 lb fuel bottles. You can pick one up for under $30. Choose one with a stable platform/base that can easily and safely hold a fairly large pot of water (to heat water for washing).
More Food (Hot/Cooked) -- Rice, pasta, instant (fat free) mashed potatoes, canned veggies, soups, pasta sauce, chili, chicken/ham, ramen, instant hot chocolate/coffee/tea, etc... Start off by cooking/eating the food in your fridge and then the freezer before it spoils. Don't buy one of those 30 day emergency food buckets and call it done. In a power outage/emergency your life will be hard
enough as it -- eating really awful tasting food for days on end only makes a bad situation worse.
More Water and/or a water filter for folks on city water. A $30 Sawyer water filter is an easy an inexpensive option plus it is small.
Paper Plates -- the cheap/thin kind to use as plate/bowl liners. You don't want to waste water on dirty dishes.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additional items to add as time/money permits, some are are optional and others may be urgent depending on your needs:
Off-Grid Heat Source -- Small kerosene or propane
heaters are a good option even for apartment dwellers.
Home Defense -- Shotgun, machete, etc... If you get a machete use it in your garden to chop down weeds/brush so you become proficient with it.
Additional Medical Supplies -- Gauze/bandages, rubbing alcohol, vet wrap, blood stop powder, gloves, benadryl, extra prescription meds and fish antibiotics etc... Venomous snakes are risk where I live so I keep Prednisone on hand (a snake bite when the roads are blocked by down
trees could be a death sentence). If you have a good relationship with your veterinarian they can really help you out.
Mylar Bags with Oxygen Absorbers -- An easy and inexpensive way to keep your dry goods shelf stable for years with no worries about them going stale or being infested by insects. The one gallon bags hold 2 boxes of pasta, 4 lbs of flour or sugar etc... Only store foods with very few ingredients and no fat (like pasta, oatmeal, plain crackers, etc...) The 5 gallon bags can hold 50 lbs of wheat/rice/corn which is great for large families and chickens/other livestock.
Generator -- Portable generators are great for keeping the freezer cold or pumping well water but IMO they
should not be relied on for necessities such as cooking and heat. They are loud, finicky and they eat up a lot of gas.
Books and Board Games especially if you have kids (their survival may depend on it if you are locked in the house with them for days on end).
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
These lists are by no means perfect but they will get you off to a good start -- often getting started is the hardest part!