Michael Cox wrote:They need less precision when laying them out. Long swales pretty much need to be perfectly on contour, or they turn into flowing streams with erosion. These half-moon swales don't need that level of precision, so are likely better suited to situation where equipment is minimal and hand tools are being used.
Plus a single one of these structures is effective in isolation. If digging by hand you could make one in a day, and just keep expanding the array in increments as time allows. Harder to do with linear swales that need to be perfectly aligned to contour and spaced and sized more carefully to handle peak rainfall events (avoiding erosion).
Nice! Your perspective makes a lot of sense to me. Thank you for sharing!
With experience and machinery, long swales on contour could be more efficient. But I personally feel drawn towards an iterative approach, and have been thinking about shorter linear swales on contour. However these semi-circles have really stuck me too. If you have any thoughts on shorter swales on contour vs these semi-circles, I'd like to hear that too.