I separate the overly neurotic sort of urban vegan idealism, from the real world as well.
Permaculture needs farmers and everybody on board making these systems work for them. i actually believe keeping animals is more of a chore and therefore does not fit my ideal lazy permaculture lifestyle.
And it is somewhat funny, but as much as Bill cracks wise at the expense of vegetarians, his own system kicked the
cattle off when he started setting it up, and he speaks about cattle being a terrible way to treat country.
And in Geoff's systems, he has lots of interns keeping things going, but the idea that his system could be left alone and "simply get better" would require that he get rid of most of his animals.
I don't mind the idea of managing overpopulation in animals, or composting road kill, but i do avoid eating them, it simply is a bad idea for optimum health, and keeping domestic animals the way most people do becomes a terrible waste of resources, although, if you don't mind the slavery, it can greatly help move systems forward and enrich soil.
If the predator load wasn't so high out here i would be running
chicken tractors and maybe even goats to prepare areas, but then i'd want to get rid of them once the areas had a permanent cover. I went through hundreds of guineas out here, or the predators did, over the course of three or so years, they ate a lot of store bought food, enriched the soil wonderfully, controlled the ticks, and the foxes, racoons, hawks, dogs, bears, got many good meals, until now i'm left with Lucky, a guinea who is imprinted on me and always locked up except when i am out there with her, but even at that, as much as she is a pet and my baby, i have to look at her and realize- one bold fox, or a few minutes straying out of sight and she could be a memory and a few feathers left behind.
Well, good luck with your systems
https://permies.com/t/30123/singles/healthy-vegan-raw-acres-central#361647 i'm putting up a few posts here as well that relate to animals in the system, the last one about
deer that might be relevant.
keep posting as your experiment moves forward, also any tidbits you think might be helpful to a fellow vegan