posted 1 month ago
I'm endorsing Phil's suggestion of paper/cardboard plus deep mulch.
But that is just the opening salvo in a long war. Your enemy wins a battle when you allow photosynthesis to replenish the energy reserves in the rhizomes. That energy is spent growing new rhizomes to spread out, and new leafy parts to harvest more light. You win a battle when you dig up rhizomes, and when you cut off the leafy parts as soon as they appear.
Deep mulch helps immensely because it forces the deep rhizomes to grow farther up before reaching the light, and it will colonize the deeper parts of the mulch instead of the hard ground. Rhizomes are very easy to pull out of the mulch, so you don't have to work so hard as you do in the video. You don't have to get the deepest roots out, but it shortens the war. With deep mulch the hard soil will be softer and easier to dig to get the last, deepest parts out.
A complementary tactic is to establish a barrier around cleared areas to block rhizomes from penetrating into the cleared area. Cardboard installed vertically in a slit trench can work, but will need replacing frequently. Sheet metal is a good choice for longer term, and very useful once you've cleared to the edge of your planned bed. Tilt the vertical barrier slightly inwards. The rhizomes will try to grow over the vertical barrier making it easy to pull them out before they make it over. Whereas the horizontal barrier alone allows the roots to encroach underneath.
Obviously, constant vigilance is the key factor. I have 2 year old beds that are completely clear, only requiring policing of the perimeter, and one year old beds that I'm still working on. With a garden fork, the roots are easy to pry out mostly whole, instead of chopping them into smaller pieces with a hoe or shovel. Smaller pieces just grow twice as fast as the original!
I have a 3 year old bed that I neglected, and the rhizomes are everywhere, but now clearing is pretty easy. The broken down deep mulch of leaves and wood chips has turned into fabulous soil that is full of earthworms and worm castings, and the rhizomes are easy to pull. I just pull back the top layer of chips, save the best soil underneath for the growing beds, fork out the rhizomes, lay down new cardboard, put the old wood chips back to cover the cardboard and replenish with more chips and leaves to make it deep enough. With the summer heat, deeper is better, especially in the walkways. I can mound up the beds a bit, cover with 10-20 cm of good compost - its ready for transplanting. The walkways get 20-30 cm. This makes them safer to walk on as wet cardboard or paper with a thin layer of mulch on top can get very slippery, and hard rainfalls have a deep reservoir to soak into.