posted 2 weeks ago
John, on timing alone you are in good shape, and I think the thing to watch most closely is not pathogens, but nitrogen.
Late November to a May lettuce harvest is roughly five to six months, so you clear the 120-day gap that William mentioned for crops that touch the soil. The one caveat is that a cold winter slows pathogen die-off a lot, and a pile that sat and aged is not the same as a pile that got properly hot-composted. So I would still wash the lettuce well, harvest the leaves above soil level rather than pulling whole muddy heads, and skip harvesting right after a hard rain when soil has splashed up onto the leaves. That is just good practice with any manure-amended bed.
The bigger practical issue is your follow-up note that the load is only about 30 percent manure and 70 percent pine shavings. Pine shavings are very high carbon, and as they break down the soil microbes will borrow available nitrogen to do that work. That is the classic reason lettuce comes up pale, yellowish, and slow in a fresh shavings bed even when the manure looks rich. Your plan to add spoiled leafy greens is a good one, since that green material helps balance the carbon, and I would keep adding greens through the winter whenever you can get them. In spring, before you plant, look at the bed honestly: if the material still looks woody and pale, add a nitrogen-rich amendment then, rather than more shavings or leaves, and give it a couple of weeks before planting.
A couple of other points from your plan:
- Oak leaves are a fine choice here. Fresh oak gets a reputation for acidity and tannins, but once leaves have rotted over winter that effect is small, and they make lovely worm food. If you can, shred them first, and leave part of the leaf layer on top as mulch instead of tilling every bit in. That protects the soil over winter and gives you something to pull back in spring to plant into.
- The herbicide question matters more than the pathogen question with horse manure. Ask the ranch what was sprayed on their hay or pasture, especially for persistent herbicides, because those can pass through a horse and through composting and still twist up garden plants. Your bean and pea pot test is exactly the right check. If you can, run it before you spread all three yards: pot up some of the mix and some plain soil, grow beans and peas for three or four weeks, and watch for cupped, twisted, or stunted growth in the manure pots. If you see that, do not put that load on food beds.
- Expect weeds. Plenty of seeds survive a horse's gut, and tilling brings more to the surface. The thick leaf mulch on top will help a lot, and pulling weeds before they set seed next spring will save you a season of work.
- Your math is reassuring, too. Three yards spread over 30 by 90 feet is only a thin layer, not a deep dump, so with aged material you are very unlikely to burn lettuce by May, especially if you do not till again in spring. Stick to your last-till plan: in spring just pull the mulch back, plant into the soil underneath, and top-dress from then on.
One last note for May in your area: lettuce will want to bolt once the heat arrives, so sow in successions and give the later sowings a bit of afternoon shade if you can. Good luck with the bed, it sounds like a solid start.