Welcome Richard! You're aiming for a fairly commonly desired climate. Mild winters, mild summers, not high humidity. You may want to define your idea of mild. I think of a mild winter as one where we rarely hit -10F. Unbearably hot is 85F.
I think you'll find plenty of places with acreage under $5k per acre if you get 5+ acres.
My guess (based on very little knowledge

) is that you could hit most of your desires in the West Virginia/Tennessee/N. Carolina area if you play with elevation. I'm not sure about the humidity though.
Many of your considerations can vary greatly in a space of 20 miles (good water, building codes, crime, neighborliness, hunting, fishing).
I'd do some research on which areas of the country meet your climate needs (cold, hot, humid, dry, rain, snow) then narrow it down farther by natural disaster worries (if you have any worries). Proximity to health care and airports could be important? Keep in mind that two spots in the same county at different elevations will have different climates. After picking a number of areas, then investigate them each for your other concerns. Easier to research topics are probably building codes, price and crime.
Then take some vacation time and visit them. Look at homesteads/houses/lots for sale and see what your money gets you. Explore the downtown and talk to the locals. See if any of them feel right.