R Grier wrote: I do find the highly specific tree choices here a bit odd, aren't we supposed to be learning to work WITH nature? Many people live in regions black locust is not native, or even can't grow. Most of us could find a native edible nut tree, but limiting the type of acceptable nut really makes this badge limited to people who grow in similar growth regions. I would really expect this wonderful cite leaned towards helping people to learn about their environment and the specific ecology of where they are and how to work with it, to be willing to make acceptable substitutions appropriate to location?
For instance black locust isn't native here, and hasn't naturalized here either, given the damage that can be caused by spreading non native species it seems like something I should avoid. But we do have honey locust. I know its night quite as useful in some ways, but I would say it's more so in others, and is also a nitrogen fixer. It seems very "permaculture" to make such acceptable substitutions if the plant is present in the area and has similar growth/benefits.
The reason for the BB being shaped the way it is. is explained earlier in the thread. For PEP (Permaculture Experience according to Paul) the tree selection makes sense for where he is located. I live in different climate, more like Mike Haasl where he doesn't utilize black locust, so I would likely conduct the BB for the PEM (Permaculture Experience according to Mike) program instead.