posted 2 months ago
I'm not an expert by any means, but here my personal take. I have a giant English walnut. Nothing ever grew under it. A couple years ago we had some huge limbs break. We pruned it severely. We now have some weeds growing under the tree. I think sometimes things like this are observed and they run with it. I'm team on the fence. Like sunflower, and a bunch of other plants they have an ability to protect there space. It really depends on what you want to grow, and how close do you want it.
I built 1/2 of a hugelkultur with English walnut wood. Both halves produced the same.
I grow veggies, fruit, herbs, and flowers. No way to keep walnut leaves out in the fall. I don't notice a difference between where there are, or were lots of walnut leaves or not.
Not only do I deal with walnut leaves, but I grow English walnut trees by the dozens, thanks to our squirrel friends. As soon as I realize what it is pull it out. But they grow right next to all the plants I want to grow, and I have never noticed any harm.
On the other side, I have an old English walnut, and the English part died. It's not a black walnut. I have tried to plant 2 bare root trees about 10 feet from this tree. Both didn't make it. I thought I did something wrong, but maybe it's the tree?
So I think like almost all garden questions the answer is it depends.
Good luck
“We can complain because rose bushes have thorns, or rejoice because thorn bushes have roses.” — Abraham Lincoln