you want temp in root cellar around 35-40 degrees F (optimum) most are warmer. my fave was an old one under a farmhouse I rented - the date scratched into the wall was 1896. It had stone walls, axe marks on the ceiling joists, and a tamped earth floor. The landlord along the way had used it for the
water heater & well pump (when they put in the indoor plumbing) so it was too warm for traditional root cellaring, but excellent for long term pantry storage as it stayed 50 degrees year around (this was zone 4, winters -20 at times). To compensate for the extreme humidity I coated (metal) canned goods with a very light coating of mineral oil (get at pharmacy at wal mart, it comes food grade). Without oil they rusted in 3 yrs, with oil good for 6 yrs (maybe longer, I moved at the 6 year point). Pails with mylar bags inside also did great. Tho I could not store taters, apples, and other cold loving things in that cellar I loved having it available as an extra "pantry". Unfortunately where I live now, (sone
it's not cold enough for root cellar - however it is offest by being able to garden thru the winter. My garden IS my root cellar now, LOL.