Rebecca, I don't see any reports of my issue with this type of oven over a gas grill. So, how can a 5" batch box be hotter than 3 burners on a gas grill?
William, I'd like to see your setup. The original Bakerstone pizza box has stone on the floor, roof, and sides. There's only a thin gap at the rear which lets the heat in but I presume that the floor of the box is also heated by gas.
I'm going to try a commercial pizza dough to see if that is the issue. I can't see why changing from butane to
wood gas makes such a difference. More likely it's a mea culpa with the dough.