There is a plaster permeated gauze tape of some sort that might work? I think that is what is used for these castings for the
treasured chest program
I used something like that for masks in a group project once but I'm not sure where the gauze was ordered from? It was easy because we just dipped the dry gauze in warm water and it was good to go.
It might be you could cut strips of gauze or muslin maybe and dip into a thin plaster like we do paper mache strips?
and then slip a stretchy knit cover over the whole thing in order to have something to pin to...
My old form, who I called Adele, was some kind of heavy fiber stuff and covered with a stretchy fabric.
...what about fiber glass? seems like you can get it in some kind of layering fiber stuff?
or, paper mache itself?
"We're all just walking each other home." -Ram Dass
"Be a lamp, or a lifeboat, or a ladder."-Rumi
"It's all one song!" -Neil Young