The 'SHTF' scenario would be a mess.
Most Americans don't have the basic skills to survive..i.e. farming, metal and
wood working, animal husbantry, build a house, security, etc..etc.
Then there is the problem of going from 2013 to 1880 in a week.
Most things we take for granted is depended on the 'grid'.
Power, communications, security, medicine, etc.
The little electrical outlet is the only thing holding society together.
No gas for farm tractors to plow, plant and harvest.
No medicine.
No antibiotics. A simple cut could be serious or even life threatening.
No running
water on most farms (pumps are electric in most places.).
Some farms would be abandoned if they have deep
wells or far away from irrigation canals.
No way to get the water to the surface without a generator. (fuel problem.)
Crops that were planted would die for lack of water.
Settlements would have to live near rivers or streams and find a way to irrigate.
Then there is a water purification problem.
For crops not a big problem, but for drinking water, it has to be purified. (Cystes, parasites etc..no antibiotics or medicine available if someone gets sick.)
Shop gear like lathes, mills, table saws, skill saws, arc welders etc. to keep the farm or settlement in repair, that runs on electric, are now expensive boat anchors unless run on a generator..(fuel problem yet again.)
All the farming will done by hand which, with even a small community to
feed, would be a full time job provided there was
enough able bodied people to do it.
Even 'if' one could find a mule or a horse, how many know how to harness and plow with them or care for them?
That's providing there is time to plow, plant and harvest and enough food to last until the first harvest without interruption.
How do they perserve the food?
How many people now a days have the skill to can,
jerk meat or smoke meat?
I suppose one could make power with
solar or wind.
But where do they find the
solar panels?. I suppose they could look for parts for an
energy system.
Do they end up 'foraging' also for the parts?; another name for looting?
And what happens when one 'foraging' group, runs into another 'foraging' group (they won't be the only ones out there looking for the same things..) or a group defending their own assets?
Then there is the problem of security.
Everybody will be spreading out foraging and no matter how isolated the farm or settlement is, it will be found sooner or later.
Farms and settlements would have a big sign on them that says 'Loot Me'.
As one poster pointed out in 'Lucifer's Hammer'..many of the looters and threats came from trained cadre.
How many people have the training and skills to address security?
Then they will need people to repair what they have. Metal workers, blacksmiths, woodworkers, leather workers etc.
How do they heat the home? Wood..no chainsaws, more work by hand.
How do they have light?
Candles?..How many people know how to make a candle? What materials are readily available in that scenario to make a candle?
Lanterns?..Fuel yet again.
I suppose one could make fuel, but how many people have that knowledge?
Even with the knowledge, they will need people with the knowledge and the tools to fabricate with the materials they can find.
A thing as simple as a nail we take for granted to build something would be important.
Blacksmiths made nails, but where do you find a blacksmith in such a scenario?
'Wanted: Blacksmith to make nails. Will trade two jars of
honey for box of nails. Contact Apocolyse Farms at coordinates 7120 on your GPS."
Of
course, the blacksmith's batteries have run out in his GPS.
Did I say back to 1880?
I meant 1840..