Tess Misch wrote:My hair on the other hand looks cleaner, but not clean. I am going to use a vinegar rinse next time, just to see if that works. My hair is kinda funky when it comes to excessive dryness in winter and oiliness in summer, so I have figure out a way to combat this the best I can. I may need to find a super environment-friendly hair soap I can use if going pooless doesn't work for me.
Leaving a word of encouragement here for you, Tess - and anyone else embarking on this wonderful no-poo adventure. Breaking the shampoo/conditioner cycle for our scalp can involve some transitioning time, and it's hard to predict just how long that will take.
And by "transition" I mean the scalp can go suuuuper greasy for a while before it gets used to the new routine.
I can't really speak to water-only - I did that for a while but it was years ago and I've forgotten how it went in the beginning. But 6 years ago, I got serious about only cleansing my scalp and hair mechanically, and only using the sebum my scalp produces to condition the length. (In plain terms, I scritch my scalp with my nails or a wooden or horn comb, give it a quick but gentle fingertip massage, then preen the sebum down the length with fingers and a boar bristle brush.)
And yes - in the beginning it involved a rather long transition period of gradually decreasing oiliness.
My transition probably took longer due to switching climates twice a year (between low humidity summers and high humidity winters), my inconsistent diet, varying stress levels, and my less-than-religious SMP (scritch, massage, preen) practice - and who knows what else that I wasn't aware of.
Deane - it's so interesting how our hair picks up environmental scents. I've often been surprised by how a scritch and a brush session will remove or greatly decrease hair smells. Campfire smoke has been the main culprit...